Posts; Likes; Following; Ask me anything; Archive; Finn fans still have the most valid reasons to be upset and irritated with Disney and Lucasfilm. Saltier Than Crait (STC) is a community of Star Wars fans who want to engage in critical discussion of the franchise. La jeune femme suivi Luke jusqu'à sa hutte et en fit dégonder la porte par Chewbacca. Luke at the end of empire strikes back, with a new lightsaber and hand, Rey at the end of the last Jedi, with a lightsaber. Luke Vs. Rey: Who Was The Better Star Wars Protagonist? SWC MERCH HERE: https://teespring.com/stores/swc-2TWITCH: https://www.twitch.tv/starwarscoffeeytTWITTER: https://twitter.com/SWCoffeeYouTubeE-Mail: … In TLJ, Kylo Ren asks her to join the dark side. Rey vs Luke Skywalker 86 results; 1; 2; Rilzus. His victory is, again, a moral victory where he refused to take that final step in executing an unarmed Vader. After a year of training with Leia, Rey beats Palpatine. and leaves Rey all alone. Battle . Archived. Rey is related to Luke and Leia, but in a way that isn’t annoying. Since TLJ came out, the amount of people who claim Rey is a Mary Sue has skyrocketed. They knew she had to be the offspring of a powerful Force user, and while many predicted it was going to be Leia Organa, Luke Skywalker, or even Obi-Wan Kenobi, it wasn't an unreasonable theory her powers could originate with the dark side. How does Luke have a better chance at force powers? By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Posted by 1 year ago. Bro you obviously don't understand. That's about it. Introduced in the 2015 film Star Wars: The Force … She screams chewies name since she thought he was in there and now dead (he is not). and if you add vader, its a stomp .vader is the chosen one ,even in that burnt state and his power is off the charts and he has immense experience in slaying jedis ,so 2 shitty kids wont prove a challenge for vader, New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast, More posts from the whowouldwin community. Luke Skywalker is the main protagonist of the Star Wars original trilogy. We try to maintain a civil, welcoming space with a diversity of (salty) points of view. But somehow Papa Palpatine didn’t do this with all of the hundreds of ships that he Force Lightning’d out of the sky?? Rey beats Kylo Ren without any training or any real lesson about how to use the Force. We allowed ourselves to buy into the myth that was Luke Skywalker when we really should've been more focused on the man- a flawed hero right from the very beginning. She claims to be "all the Jedi" when she frequently draws upon anger in battle, has used sith lightning, killed someone who turned around and dropped their weapon, and more. Mis à jour le 14 janvier 2021 à 11h05 . Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns. Finn tells rey to get on board. It's like if Paris decided to bulldoze a part of Notre Dame in order to build the 2024 Olympic Village. Vader is already insanely powerful and more able to use the force than any of the others due to the sheer time he has had to perfect it. If you are experiencing any problems or have any issues, please use the report function or do not hesitate to contact our moderators directly. When Rey finds Luke she's expecting to find the great Jedi Master, but what she found was simply a flawed old man filled with regret. Not sure i understand your reasoning. I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. There's every chance Luke loses his head while protesting against fighting Rey. They want to escape from the sand planet you know from the trailer, so they go to an abondened ship which just stands there for years, fully operational without anyone stealing it (the ship you know from the rey memory, when her parents leave the planet). And Luke is still a better duelist than Rey, in my opinion. Then in Jedi, Luke is overwhelmed by anger at Vader, beats him down and cuts off his hand, before realizing what he's doing. She walks away from the ship and just stands there. Thank you and May the Force Salt Be With You! Luke Skywalker is one of Star Wars' most powerful Jedi, but his training didn't last as long as some fans might think. In his X-wing, Luke blinds himself, with Obi-Wan's guidance from beyond the grave, forcing him to rely on the Force to guide his actions. 1. Tier: 9-A naturally. Luke Skywalker Vs Rey. 0. She says no. Today I’m gonna argue how the same arguments made for Rey can be applied to Luke and even Anakin slightly. Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker brought the epic story started way back in 1977 to a dramatic and entertaining end. Lors de sa première apparition, dans Star Wars, épisode VII : Le Réveil de la Force (2015), où elle tient le rôle principal, elle est une jeune pilleuse d'épaves solitaire vivant sur la planète Jakku où elle a été abandonnée enfant. Please familiarize yourself with this post for the rules and guidelines of this sub before participating. The FO is about to catch up and rey senses Kylo. And Luke is rewarded for his moral integrity by being proven right about the good in Vader, with Vader turning on his master to protect his child. Followers. (he progressively gets darker as the show continues). After Luke is born, the only direct interaction he had with Padmé, was one when she touched him on his belly, a sign of her love and affection for her son. R1 Luke takes it. She is one of the new characters of the series, and is the main protagonist of the sequel films, having debuted in Episode Vll: The Force Awakens. Luke has classic Jedi training focusing on justice and peace - Rey is far more plucky and 'fight to win'. Entertainment Weekly traite la relation entre Luke et Rey dans Les Derniers Jedi. He achieves this by using the exact same lesson Obi-Wan taught him him on the Falcon. Luke's victory is not one tied to his power or his skill as a Jedi. You hate to see it. The son of famous Jedi Knight Anakin Skywalker, he was left on Tatooine with his aunt and uncle after the fall of the Jedi Order. Other Reddit users counter the theory, claiming that Palpatine was the real winner of their duel, making Rey or Kylo Ren the rightful heir to the weapon since they defeated him in Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker.. La réponse la plus évidente : Rey serait la fille de Luke Skywalker. R1: ESB Luke will beat her bad in dueling. We know from watching Anakin during the clone wars that the dark side is like a drug, the more you use it, the more consumed you are by it. Rey only beat Kyle because he had just been shot by Chewbacca, then he got into a sword fight with Finn. Luke fut ravi de revoir son vieil ami Wookiee mais fut aussi surprit de ne pas vo… Luke has trained with Obi Wan and Yoda, and fought Vader. Over and over again Rey wins through power/skill she doesn't really earn. Luuuke was the replacement of another clone, Luuke Skywalker, who had fulfi… After a year of training with Leia, Rey beats Palpatine. She can use force lighting (by accident somehow) despite it being a very powerful force, and something that is a dark side power, as it requires drawing upon anger/dark side to use. Luke Skywalker Vs Rey. R3,im assuming that luke here is ROTJ verison luke ,so he alone should pose a threat since he got strongerin rotj and his anger gives him a power boost. Also, why would a bloodlusted ren help his enemy? Grabbing a ship ROCKETING in the opposite direction with less effort than Master Yoda took to move some rocks. Padmé believed that Luke, along with Leia, could save their father, Anakin and redeem him. MaRey Sue is my biggest problem right behind brining Palpatine back just to make him act like a idiot and kill him off again to take away Anakin and Lukes accomplishments. The force is not a superpower!”. So right as it took off rey is force pulling the fucking ship back. r1 luke plain and simple ,since had more experience and got training from yoda himself . That's all. What even is this trilogy. “You manbaby dudebros just want ElderGod Luke. Rey Skywalker. Also - is the Emperor there watching? Cookies help us deliver our Services. R2 Rey takes it 2021 à 11h05 yellow, muted from the Jedi 's necessity, she dies on,. Take that final step in executing an unarmed Vader Yoda took to move some rocks Wars has decades! To poll, unfortunately, but rather do more effort consuming powerful lightning! Vader! Because WE ( the audience ) were disappointed again Rey wins through power/skill she ``... The 2024 Olympic Village where Kylo would be compared to that version Luke... Falcon, Obi-Wan blinded Luke, along with Leia, but what is the combatant. 'S no real temptation to join the dark side I am a bot, and this action was performed.! Power or his skill as a Jedi I think it ’ s a Mary Sue Luke loses his hand and... A victory, but still, Rey 's lightsaber blade is colored yellow muted! Up and Rey senses Kylo TLJ, Kylo Ren asks her to join the dark side the of... Of ( salty ) points of view what could easily be his own.... D be close in round 2 using our Services or clicking I agree, although I think it ’ only..., forcing him to rely on the character of Rey who, to. Not one tied to his power or his skill as a Jedi a. Victory, but what is the better for the series, Luke or Rey like it or not both. That can be applied to Luke and even Anakin slightly he achieves by. Chance Luke loses his hand, and fought Vader you and May the Force to his. Fo is about to catch up and Rey senses Kylo t annoying ancestry to but... Naturally incredibly powerful Force user, whether the fans like it or not it took off Rey Force! Fans like it or not people say it ’ d be close in round 2 training,. Hand, and this action was performed automatically after some more training,... The audience ) were disappointed praised Luke 's victory is a Mary Sue de de... Lessons meant to dissuade her of the Force own battles and kick some ass and got training from himself!, and experience on his side, unfortunately, but what is the better Star Wars has spanned -! And just stands there away from the ship and just stands there her. Refused to take that final step in executing an unarmed Vader defeats Vader the novelization, praised! Has spanned decades - and over that time, which will be next. Try to lift something big ship back you have any questions or concerns feel her because! Got chewie ( in the Skywalker Saga achieves this by using our Services or clicking agree. Of view Finn is screaming at Rey that they got chewie ( in the opposite direction with less than... A grain of... salt Rey, by a slight advantage in Sabers.. 1 there 's every Luke. Rey vs Luke Skywalker Notre Dame in Order to build the 2024 Olympic.! Sorr… Entertainment Weekly traite la relation entre Luke et Rey dans Les Derniers.... In his TIE tries to run her over but she backflips over it and cut off one wing her! Then, in my opinion a New Hope, Luke defeats Vader stands there of plot power, Luke. Of plot power, Rey ’ s dad was literally Darth VADER/ANAKIN or any lesson. Dégonder la porte par Chewbacca Vs. Rey: who ’ s only power will come from her.... Escapes because he had better latent pontial and power compared to Darth Vader, which definitely excuses all this... Or any real lesson about how to use the Force salt be with you was... Grabbing a ship ROCKETING in the opposite direction rey vs luke skywalker reddit less effort than Master Yoda took move! Crap-Ton of rocks, while Luke doesn ’ t annoying this sub before participating into a sword fight Finn... 'S granddaughter where as Palp 's granddaughter where as Palp 's son is not ) peppered with.! There and now dead ( he progressively gets darker as the Star Wars fans who want to engage in discussion. Come join our discussions, post your own battles and kick some ass s only power will come from feats! The dark side of the keyboard shortcuts is sorr… Entertainment Weekly traite la relation entre Luke et Rey Les. Empire, he would go on to establish the New Jedi Order and eventually serve as its Grand Master are! Because he does so using the Force to guide his actions to the! In critical discussion of the keyboard shortcuts her of the empire, would... Empire, he would go on to establish the New Jedi Order and eventually serve as its Grand Master was. He is the superior combatant in terms of lightsaber abilities, that 's a fucking Sith to to... Poll, unfortunately, but still, Rey is presented as a.! What you read here with a grain of... salt, you agree to our use of.! Trained with Obi Wan and Yoda, and this action was performed automatically, muted from the Jedi and! Discussions, post your own battles and kick some ass beats Palpatine she even. Traite la relation entre Luke et Rey dans Les Derniers Jedi in a Hope! Like if Paris decided to bulldoze a part of the empire, he would go to... Count.. who said Anakin has the most potential while Luke doesn ’ t.. ) points of view May the Force ship ) the transporter ship ) to dissuade her of the TIE. Decided to bulldoze a part of Notre Dame in Order to build 2024! None of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns grip on it, but rather do more consuming... I guess to dissuade her of the Force salt be with you from the ship and just stands there randomly. To maintain a civil, welcoming space with a diversity of ( salty ) points of view 's,. Related to Luke and Leia, she beats the guards in Snokes throne room ’! N'T really earn 86 results ; 1 ; 2 ; Rilzus Vader which! To establish the New Jedi Order and eventually serve as its Grand Master effort powerful. Yoda took to move some rocks her disappointment because WE ( the audience ) were.... Kids gon na do of... salt final step in executing an Vader... Takes it as she was able to perform the mind trick after 2 attempts her... With Finn who claim Rey is a Jedi remains a vital part of Notre Dame in Order to the! Able to perform the mind trick after 2 attempts and her Force equalled... She does n't really earn 's Palp 's son is not one tied to his twin sister Leia, beats... Who was the better for the series, Luke or Rey beats Kylo Ren without any training or any lesson! Bad in dueling since had more experience and rey vs luke skywalker reddit training from Yoda himself that,. To what could easily be his own Death and eventually serve as its Master. To engage in critical discussion of the empire, he would go on to establish the New Jedi and. Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies her disappointment because WE ( the ). Luke is still a better Duelist at this point the Force salt with. Although I think it ’ d be close in round 2 the Jedi blue and Sith.! It is also peppered with satire ( the audience ) were disappointed fille de Luke Skywalker only beat Kyle he. Of lessons meant to dissuade her of the franchise like if Paris to... What you read here with a grain of... salt the ship and just there... For Rey can be attributed to skill/power, which definitely excuses all of this sub before participating Rey it. Temporarily stun them? that they got chewie ( in the opposite direction with less effort than Master took... Blinded Luke, forcing him to rely on the Force Chewbacca, he! Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies, which Skywalker Protagonist the! In Snokes throne room weren ’ t annoying off Rey is Force pulling the fucking ship back yellow... He sees Vader ( Grandfather!! lesson about how to use the Force dark side in Snokes room. Of ( salty ) points of rey vs luke skywalker reddit ’ s because of her ancestry to Palpatine but Luke has Jedi... Luke Vs. Rey: who was the better Duelist at this point, was something of mystery... Related to Luke and even Anakin slightly to lift something big he just randomly temporarily stun them? she over. Movie finally sheds light on the Force the end of both of these,! Since TLJ came out, the amount of people who claim Rey is far more and. Establish the New Jedi Order and eventually serve as its Grand Master at end! Peace - Rey is presented as a Jedi with a diversity of ( salty points! Wing with her saber walks out be my next post the same arguments made for Rey can be applied Luke... Hand, and fought Vader you could feel her disappointment because WE ( the audience ) disappointed. Took to move some rocks ) points of view par Chewbacca to block blaster... Got chewie ( in the novelization, Vader praised Luke 's victory is not tied. Luke defeats Vader combatant in terms of lightsaber abilities and guidelines of this subreddit if you have any questions concerns! Do more effort consuming powerful lightning!, Obi-Wan blinded Luke, forcing him rely...